National Association of the Deaf

The National Association of the Deaf (NAD) applauds the decision of Judge Kathleen Feeney of the Family Division of the 17th Circuit Court of Kent County in Grand Rapids, Michigan on Friday, October 4, 2002 to uphold the rights of parents in their opposition to court-ordered elective surgery for their children. Judge Feeney ruled that the court does not have the authority to order cochlear implants for two deaf children who are temporary wards of the state, when their parents oppose such procedures.

The court recognized that cochlear implantation surgery is elective in nature, and that the state does not have the authority to require such surgery over the parents' objection.

NAD Executive Director Nancy J. Bloch observed court proceedings and participated in a parental rights rally outside the courtroom that was organized by state and local deaf community leaders, including Michigan Deaf Association President Richard Harkleroad. Bloch said “this is a significant decision for parents nationwide, deaf or hearing. The NAD recognizes the right of parents to make informed choices for their deaf and hard of hearing children, including the use of cochlear implants and all other assistive devices, and strongly supports the development of the whole child with emphasis on language and literacy.”

Bloch also underscored her remarks, urging Kent County Prosecutor William Forsyth and attorney Joseph Tevlin “to respect the rights of Lee Larsen and her husband to determine what is best for their children, and not to appeal the judge’s October 4 decision.” The NAD will continue to be vigilant by closely monitoring this case.